Does God Really Want Your Money? The Truth About Tithing Nobody Talks About

Key Takeaways:

• Tithing means giving the first 10% of your income to your local church — not what's left over.
• Offerings are anything you give beyond your regular tithe.
• Tithing isn't about God needing your money — it's about you learning to trust Him with yours.
• You can tithe while paying off debt. In fact, you should.

Let's Be Honest About Tithing

Real talk, family.

Tithing is one of those topics that makes people uncomfortable. Some people feel guilty because they're not doing it. Others feel confused about the rules. And some have been burned by churches that made giving feel more like pressure than purpose.

So let's clear the air.

Tithing is not a scam. It's not a guilt trip. And it's definitely not just for people who have it all figured out financially.

It's a biblical principle that has been practiced for thousands of years — and when you understand why it exists, it changes everything about how you see your money.

Let's get into it.

What Is a Tithe, Really?

The word tithe literally means a tenth. So when you tithe, you're giving 10% of your income to your local church.

But here's the part most people miss — it's not just how much you give. It's when you give it.

Proverbs 3:9 says: "Honor the Lord with your wealth, with the firstfruits of all your crops."

Firstfruits. Not last fruits. Not whatever's left after the bills, the subscriptions, and the dinner out on Friday night. The first portion. Before anything else.

That's the design. And when you flip the script — when giving becomes the first line in your budget instead of the last — something shifts. Not just in your finances. In your mindset. In your faith. In how you see everything you have.

That's what tithing is really about.

Tithes vs. Offerings — They're Not the Same Thing

People say "tithes and offerings" like they're one word. But they're two very different things, and understanding the difference matters.

A tithe is the first 10% of your income, given consistently to your local church. It's not optional. It's not seasonal. It's the foundation of a generous life.

An offering is anything you give above and beyond that 10%. It could be an extra gift to your church, support for a ministry you believe in, helping a family in your community who's going through a hard season, or giving your time and skills to serve others.

Think of it this way — the tithe is the floor. The offering is where generosity gets to breathe and grow.

Once you're out of debt and building real wealth, the offering is where things get exciting. That's when you get to be the blessing you always wanted to be.

Why Should Christians Tithe?

I'm not here to guilt you. That's not my style.

But I will tell you the truth — because that's what I'd want someone to do for me.

Tithing is one of the most powerful financial and spiritual decisions you can make. Not because of a formula. Not because of a transaction. But because of what it does to your heart.

It reminds you who the real provider is.

When you give first, you're making a declaration: My security doesn't come from this paycheck. It comes from God. That's a mindset shift that no budgeting app, no side hustle, and no salary increase can give you.

Malachi 3:10 says to test God in this. I have. And I've watched thousands of people in this community do the same. The results speak for themselves.

It breaks the grip of greed.

Generosity is the cure for discontentment. When you give, your focus moves from what you don't have to how much you've already been given. That kind of gratitude brings a peace that money alone will never buy.

It fuels real work in your community.

Your tithe isn't just a number on a giving statement. It's fuel for your church to serve people, support families, run programs, and make a real difference in your community. That matters more than most people realize.

Do You Have to Tithe to Be a Christian?

No. Let me be clear about that.

Tithing doesn't earn you God's love. You already have it. Matthew 23:23 reminds us that Jesus was more concerned with justice, mercy, and faithfulness than with the mechanics of giving.

This isn't about a rule. It's about your heart.

2 Corinthians 9:7 says: "Each of you should give what you have decided in your heart to give, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver."

Cheerful. Not stressed. Not guilty. Not because someone pressured you from a pulpit.

The goal is a generous spirit — a life lived with open hands. Tithing is one of the most practical ways to build that. But it starts with the heart, not the math.

The Real Questions People Ask About Tithing

"Should I tithe if I'm paying off debt?"

Yes. And here's why.

I know it feels backwards. You're staring at your debt, the numbers feel overwhelming, and giving away 10% sounds like the last thing you should do right now.

But the discipline it takes to tithe when it's hard is the same discipline that gets you out of debt. You can't separate the two.

Now — if you genuinely cannot cover your basic needs, that's a different conversation. But for most people, the tithe fits in the budget when you get honest about your spending. Cut the subscriptions. Pack your lunch. Make the tithe non-negotiable.

One important note: While you're in debt payoff mode, hold off on extra offerings beyond your tithe. Put every extra dollar toward your debt snowball. But keep tithing. That's the move.

"Do I tithe on my gross income or my net?"

This one is between you and God.

Some people tithe on gross — before taxes. Others tithe on net — after taxes. The point isn't to get lost in the math. It's to give consistently, intentionally, and cheerfully.

Pick one. Be consistent. And don't let the calculation become an excuse to delay.

"What if I don't go to church?"

Giving to a charity or ministry is generous — and I respect that. But technically, a tithe goes to your local church. That's the biblical design.

If you're not connected to a church right now, that's worth addressing. Find a community of faith where you can grow, give, and be poured into. The tithe and the local church are meant to go together.

"Can I count my tithe as a tax deduction?"

Absolutely — and there's nothing wrong with that. Being a good steward means using every legal tool available to manage your money well. Take the deduction. It doesn't make your gift any less meaningful or your heart any less generous.

"Should I tithe on a gift or inheritance?"

Scripture doesn't require it. But if you feel led to give, give. Generosity is always the right direction. Pray about it and let God lead you.

"How do I give more as my income grows?"

This is my favorite question — because it means you're thinking about legacy, not just survival.

When your income goes up, your opportunity to give goes up too. You can fund mission trips. Support families in need. Sponsor kids for programs that change their lives. Surprise someone with a blessing they'll never forget.

The more you build, the more you get to give. That's the beauty of doing this the right way.

How to Start Tithing — Even If It Feels Impossible

Here's the plan. Simple. No excuses.

Step 1: Start with prayer.
This is a heart issue before it's a money issue. Ask God to open your hands and soften your grip. Start there — everything else follows.

Step 2: Put the tithe first in your budget.
Before rent. Before groceries. Before anything. Line one. If it's not in the budget, it won't happen. Period.

Step 3: Set it up automatically.
Most churches have online giving. Set up automatic withdrawals so it happens before you even think about it. Remove the friction. Remove the temptation.

Step 4: Start where you are.
If 10% feels impossible right now, start with what you can — 2%, 5%, whatever it is. Build toward 10%. The habit matters more than the perfect number on day one.

Conclusion

Family, here's what I need you to walk away with.

Tithing is not a tax. It's not a rule you follow to stay in good standing with God. It's an act of trust. It's you saying — out loud, with your wallet — I believe my provider is bigger than my paycheck.

And I promise you this: you cannot out-give God. I've tried. This community has tried. It doesn't work that way.

So whether you're just starting your financial journey or you're deep in the debt snowball, make the tithe non-negotiable. Put it first. Give cheerfully. And watch what God does with the other 90%.

Your move: Open your budget right now and make giving line one. If you don't have a budget yet, that's your first step — and I've got everything you need at anthonyoneal.com.

Now I want to hear from you — have you ever tithed when it felt impossible? What happened? Drop it in the comments below. Let's build together.

Keep building,

‍